The Fellowship of the Ring by J.R.R. Tolkein
Autumn means a lot of things to a lot of different people. For some it means scary stories around a campfire, for others it means pumpkin spice lattes and cozy scarves. For me, it will always mean Hobbits. Nothing feels more natural to me as reaching for Tolkein as soon as I see the leaves start to change colour. I won’t insult your intelligence by acting as if saying Lord of the Rings is great is a hot take but Tolkein’s simple but powerful story of the forces of goodness and friendship and love and all that is beautiful coming together to save the world will never not hit me right in the feels. It is perfect and it’s what every fantasy writer since Tolkein has been trying to capture, with varying degrees of success. Fellowship is the ultimate comfort read for me and reuniting with Frodo, Sam and all the rest of the Fellowship always feels like returning home again after a long journey.
The List by Yomi Adegoke
Ola has everything going for her. She’s a successful journalist at a feminist magazine, she’s a role model for young black women and she is due to marry her very handsome podcaster boyfriend in just one month’s time, in what promises to be the wedding of the year for the bougie London media set. That all changes when The List is posted on Twitter. The List is a crowdsourced collection of names of men in the public eye accused of everything from garden variety misogyny to sexual harassment to full on sexual assault. Ola’s boss immediately sets her the task of writing an article about The List and normally this is the sort of assignment that she would tackle with gusto. However, this time something has changed. This time her fiancé’s name is on The List. I would categorise this novel as less a story and more of a vehicle to explore the complicated implications of our online culture of anonymity, vigilanteism and black and white morality when it comes up against the love you have for a real, flesh and blood person who you trust and know. It was compulsively readable and also deeply stressful and thought-provoking. Perfect for if you’re looking for a book club pick that will guarantee lively discussion.
The Fraud by Zadie Smith
Many thanks to Netgalley and Penguin UK for this ARC of Zadie Smith’s first historical fiction novel, truly a union of two of my favourite things. One of the best things about Smith’s writing is that way that she can identify and seamlessly weave together seemingly disparate stories and narratives to tell one unified story that leaves you in no doubt of her genius. Here she has centred her story around an historical event called the Tichborne Trial, in which the country was divided over whether a man was truly the long lost Sir Roger Tichborne or a fraud. Our two narrators are Mrs. Touchet, an elderly housekeeper and cousin to a fading literary talent, and Andrew Bogle, a former slave from Jamaica who has aligned himself with ‘Sir Roger’ and finds himself the star witness in the trial. Both are outsiders in society and both are all too aware of the ways in which those on top deceive and exploit those below. This is an engrossing and extremely well-researched novel and what it lacks in narrative momentum, it makes up in power. Smith fans will not be disappointed.
Yellowface by Rebecca F. Kuang
This book had me under a spell for the approximately 24 hours it took for me to read it. Yellowface is the story of June Hayward, a mediocre white author whose debut novel quietly flopped and is now struggling with writer’s block. Meanwhile, her college best friend, Athena Liu, is a literary superstar, churning out novels that are both beautifully written and widely loved. One night, as the two women catch up at Athena’s apartment, Athena suddenly dies, leaving the just-finished manuscript of her latest novel unguarded and ripe for the taking. June steals the manuscript, finishing it off, making it her own and publishing under her racially ambiguous new pen-name, Juniper Song, and finally gets the critical recognition and popularity that she feels she so richly deserves. But Athena won’t be erased so easily and it is one thing to tell a lie and quite another to keep it going in perpetuity. Yellowface is an absolutely gripping novel about racism, cultural appropriation and who is the true owner of a story. June is such a perfectly constructed unreliable narrator, one moment flirting with our sympathies and the next doing something so completely morally bankrupt that my mouth was left hanging open. And yet for all of her (many, many many) flaws, she holds her audience rapt, sitting on the edge of their seat waiting to see what she will do next. Kuang is rocketing her way to the top of my list of favourite authors, not only are her plots utterly gripping but the writing is so sharp and the characters feel so real that when you’re reading her work it’s as if she has you by the throat.
Unlikeable Female Characters by Anna Bogutskaya
What makes a female character unlikeable? Is she a nag like Breaking Bad’s Skyler White? Is she a total psycho like Gone Girl’s Amy Dunne? Or is she just a mean girl in the style of Regina George or Katherine Merteuil? Bogutskaya defines an unlikeable female character as one who reveals the messier parts of her personality and doesn’t fall into conventional standards of morality. As you’ll see from my reviews this month (and every other month), I love an ‘unlikeable female character’ and I’m not alone. They’re often the most interesting characters on the screen and in recent years, shows like Fleabag and Killing Eve have won piles of awards for their portrayals of women getting up to all sorts of messy and toxic behaviour. Bogutskaya traces the development of the unlikeable female character right from pre-Hays Code Hollywood to the present day, paying homage to to all of the brilliant women who brought these characters to life along the way. Whether or not you consider yourself a film buff, this is a fascinating historical and cultural analysis.
Wuthering Heights by Emily Brontë
On wild, wet and rainy October nights, there is nothing that feels more appropriate than busting out the Brontë. This tangled and toxic tale of revenge, generational trauma and the all-consuming, obsessive and incredibly destructive love between Cathy and Heathcliff is a perfect seasonal read, especially when the rain is hitting your window so hard you feel like you have to double check it’s not the ghost of Cathy begging to be let in. I must say though, my favourite part of rereading Wuthering Heights on this occasion was explaining the plot to my husband, whose familiarity with the plot begins and ends with Kate Bush and was fully under the impression that it was a Jane Austen-style romance. Watching his little face fall as I explained just what kind of sociopaths basically everyone in this book is was almost as entertaining as Brontë’s story.
The Trespasser by Tana French
Another fantastic seasonal read. Nothing says spooky season like a murder and goodness knows the Dublin Murder Squad series if full of those (the clue is in the name). Our heroine in this book is Antoinette Conway, the lone female and non-white member of the murder squad and consequently the object of frequent workplace harassment and bullying. Her only ally is her partner, Stephen, who sticks by her even as they get landed with rubbish case after rubbish case by the old boys’ network. Understandably though the whole situation is making Antoinette pretty prickly and paranoid, so when a simple domestic homicide case starts to seem a lot more complicated than it first appeared, Antoinette is questioning her sanity. But is it paranoia if they really are all out to get you? And is Antoinette willing to risk her career to bring down a murderer who might be hiding a little close to home? Maybe even in her own squad room? This was a brilliant end to the series and I think Antoinette was my favourite protagonist yet. I’m sad to see her and the rest of the squad go, but thankfully French has plenty more books to keep me going.
The Stone Sky by N.K. Jemisin
The final instalment in the incredible Broken Earth trilogy, The Stone Sky completely lives up to the potential of the previous books in the series. Here at the end of the world, we find Essun and Nassun on a collision course with each other. Essun, having mastered the power of the Obelisk Gate and seen the way in which orogenes and stills live together in harmony in Castrima, is ready to recapture the moon, end the Seasons once and for all and to build a world in which young orogenes can grow up free. Her long-daughter, Nassun, has very different ideas. Having also harnessed the power of the Obelisks and become harden by the evils she has seen since the start of the Season, Nassun doesn’t see a world worth saving, only one that deserves to be burned to the ground. What is so beautiful about this series is the way the Jemisin has built this world on an epic and grand scale and filled it with incredible magical potential and yet the relationship between Nassun and Essun is the absolute heart of everything, even though they are miles and miles apart for the vast majority of the series. Yes the stakes are high and the fate of the world is at risk, but so much of it just falls away when the two of them are reunited, seeing how they have changed and reckoning with the trauma they both carry and the desperate love that underpins it all. A beautiful end to an incredibly special series.
Killers of the Flower Moon by David Grann
This had been on my TBR list for a little while and the imminent release of Martin Scorsese’s adaption of it gave me a kick up the ass to finally pick it up. I am so, so, glad I did – what an absolutely wild ride! I cannot believe the events of this book actually happened. If I had been given this book and had been told it was fiction I would have thought the whole thing was cartoonishly overwrought and that no actual people are this straight up evil, but once again humanity strives to prove me wrong. The book revolves around the Osage tribe, a group of Native Americans who, after being driven from their ancestral lands by white settlers, cheaply purchased rocky and unfarmable land on which to resettle. In a rare stroke of luck for the Native Americans, that land turned out to be bursting with oil reserves that they were able to lease to oil barons for astronomical fees. Overnight, every member of the Osage tribe became fabulously wealthy but their luck quickly turned sour as members of the tribe start to die mysteriously. What unfurls is a story of corruption, murder, fraud and betrayal, sprinkled liberally with huge amounts of racism towards the Osage people, with twists and turns that will make your head spin. Simultaneously a fascinating true crime tale and a vital story of the resilience and suffering of the Osage people, this was a truly excellent read and had me exclaiming ‘Wait WHAT?’ out loud every ten minutes.
Moon Over Soho by Ben Aaronovitch
By this point in October it was time to make a move from depressingly true crime to truly fantastical crime and so I cracked open the second book in Ben Aaronovitch’s Rivers of London series. We once again meet our protagonist, Peter Grant, an apprentice wizard and one of the Met’s only officers trained to tackle supernatural and magical crime, and this time he’s finding himself haunted by the echoes of jazz standards emanating from corpses. As he starts to investigate what seems to be a case of a ‘jazz vampire’ who sucks the life out of musicians as they perform, Peter finds himself wandering deeper into London’s magical underworld than he ever has before. Once again, Aaronovitch has crafted an immensely readable love letter to London and magic, two things profoundly dear to my heart. My only quibble is that the big twist did seem a touch obvious, but perhaps that’s just because I’m less inclined to be taken in by mysteriously helpful, attractive and horny associates of the deceased than Peter is.
Baba Yaga Laid An Egg by Dubravka Ugrešić
This was a strange little book but that feels fitting given the strangeness of Baba Yaga herself. When a book tries to capture the essence of a woman most famous for living alone in the woods in a house that moves about on a pair of chicken’s legs (icon behaviour imo), you can hardly expect it to be a straightforward tale. Like all old stories this book was confusing and often didn’t quite follow a logic that would make sense in the ‘real world’ and yet the experience of letting it wash over you was decidedly a pleasant one. Because I am an incurable nerd for all things mythology, my favourite section was the last one, which took the form of a letter from an academic that provided analysis of the stories that preceded it. I learned so much about Slavic and Eastern European folklore from this section and it really helped me better appreciate the earlier parts of the book. Putting that structure and guidance in at the last minute actually really added to my experience of reading this novel but I can also see the argument for letting the full unruliness of Baba Yaga run free and offering no explanation whatsoever!
Fragile Things: Short Fictions and Wonders by Neil Gaiman
This gorgeous collection of short stories and poems by Neil Gaiman achieves a perfect balance between delightful and creepy, often within the same story. My highlights were A Study in Emerald, a twisted marriage of Arthur Conan Doyle and H.P. Lovecraft that fed a need I didn’t know I had, Harlequin Valentine, a fabulously eerie love story in which Harlequin (quite literally) gives his heart away and Forbidden Brides of the Faceless Slaves in the Secret House of the Night of Dread Desire, a gorgeously goofy gothic parody and paean to why we read stories that left my cockles feeling toasty warm. I also have to give a shout out to Other People, a story which I cannot say I enjoyed. Rather it left me feeling so disturbed and shaken that I profoundly regretted reading it right before bed. However, this is because it is a truly masterful work of short fiction and I recommend it, along with the rest of the collection, to any Gaiman fans brave enough to crack it open.
The Final Empire by Brandon Sanderson
I have finally hopped on board the Brandon Sanderson hype train and I am now so angry at myself for not having read his books sooner. But at least I now have plenty to catch up on! The Final Empire is the first book in his Mistborn series which features magical warriors or ‘allomancers’ who can harness the power of different metals to wield superhuman strength, influence to the emotions of others or even propel themselves through the air. These powers belong exclusively to the aristocratic classes and are forbidden to the Skaa, an oppressed caste of slaves whose labour and suffering sustains the mighty empire of the immortal and all-powerful Lord Ruler. Enter a group of allomancer criminals who are ready to pull off the biggest heist of all time, leading a Skaa rebellion to overthrow the Lord Ruler and seize his treasury. Led by the charismatic Kelsier, a half-Skaa with an extremely personal grudge against the Lord Ruler, they might just have a chance of bringing this off. But their chances look a lot brighter once they recruit Vin, a half-Skaa orphan of mysterious origins whose powers might surpass even Kelsier’s. However, she has learned to expect betrayal around every corner and while mastering her powers seems to come naturally to her, learning to trust her newfound crew might be harder. Honestly this book was absolutely perfect, full of detailed world-building, a super cool magic system and, most importantly, just a really bloody good story. I’m going to have to sit on my hands to stop myself from going straight to the next book in the series.
The Haunting of Hill House by Shirley Jackson
This is the perfect short read for spooky October nights. The Haunting of Hill House is a masterclass in tension, suspense and dread in which an occult scholar attempts to stage a research trip to a haunted house to observe supernatural phenomena. While his assistants, the vivacious Theodora, insecure Eleanor and charismatic Luke, are not true believers in the paranormal, even they can sense from the very beginning that something is deeply, deeply wrong with Hill House. As strange events become harder and harder to explain away, their initial joviality begins to fray into fractious paranoia, almost as if Hill House itself is seeking to isolate and divide them. Almost as if Hill House wants them vulnerable. Almost as if Hill House has no intention of letting them leave. Read by yourself at night at your own risk, every bump and creak in your house will suddenly start sounding a lot more sinister than usual.
What You Are Looking For Is in the Library by Michiko Aoyama
After the horrors of Jackson, I needed something distinctly cuddlier to cleanse the palette and What You Are Looking For Is in the Library certainly delivered. Aoyama’s novel is essentially five interrelated short stories about people at a crossroads in their lives but are unsure of what direction to take. Whether it’s seeking new purpose after retirement, balancing motherhood and a working life or trying to find the courage to follow a long-cherished dream, each of our protagonists needs a little push to help them find their next step. Fate brings each of them to Hatori Community House and its library, which is run by the mysterious but highly-skilled librarian, Sayuri Komachi. Although people come to her thinking that they know what they need, Ms Komachi seems to have a special ability to identify the exact, often unexpected, book that will give them the guidance they need. This was a real heartwarmer and perfect for anyone looking to embrace the cosy side of autumn rather than the scary one.
Of Ghosts and Goblins by Lafcadio Hearn
I appreciate this may not be the most relatable anecdote that I have, but if you grew up in Ireland and studied Japanese, you heard a lot about Lafcadio Hearn. Hearn is a Greek-Irish writer who travelled to Japan in the late 19th century and who gathered stories of Japanese folklore, translated them and introduced them to a Western audience. Being the great link between Japan and Ireland, he came up a lot over the course of my study of the language for my Leaving Certificate and so I couldn’t resist buying a beautiful, clothbound anthology of his work when I stumbled across it in a bookstore. I read the whole thing in one go on Halloween night and happily lost myself in the strange and eerie world of Japanese demons, goblins and spirits. I highly recommend this to anyone looking for an atmospheric and spooky read this autumn.